iPhone v. BlackBerry: Which to Choose?

All I heard for a while was predictions for the death of the BlackBerry. And then everyone around me said you can’t get third-party apps for the iPhone. When you can, then the BlackBerry will be dead. Then the iPhone SDK was announced and the death watch of the BlackBerry started again.

Personally, I don’t see it for two main reasons. Here’s why:

1. IT Departments. At big companies across the country, IT departments love the BlackBerry. RIM’s secret sauce, as I learned last year at the BlackBerry Wireless Enterprise Symposium, is not so much the device but instead its ultra-cool server software that lets IT professionals control those pesky little devices. BlackBerry Enterprise Server doesn’t just control the interchange with Microsoft Exchange and other email systems. In addition, it gives the IT department complete control over those devices. There are hundreds of pre-canned permissions and the ability to generate more.

In the enterprise, RIM is the leader — Apple is playing catch-up — so RIM doesn’t have to develop ultra-cool, innovative devices. All market leaders have to do is generally keep up with the joneses and they will keep the market. And that’s what RIM continues to do, its latest being the BlackBerry Bold just announced last week. Improved layout, check. Improved browsing, check. Wifi, check. A handful of other things people have been dying for, check. Good enough to keep Apple off our rears in the enterprise, check.

2. Email. The second reason is a usability issue. I have not used an iPhone but I have used an iPod Touch. The browser and interface are top-notch, way above and beyond what anyone else has done. But where the device falls short is when it comes to typing anything. It’s horrible. So the market splits: are you an email and texting and calendar and tasks person? Or are you a browsing and music and YouTube person? If you fall into the former, like me, then BlackBerry does it since I am primarily email and secondarily browsing. If you prefer gaming and entertainment, the latter is for you.

So in my mind, BlackBerry isn’t dead in the consumer market, either. It all comes down to taste. But what is clear — and to me has been for the past year — is that it is a two-horse race. The likes of Microsoft’s Windows Mobile, Palm’s operating system and Symbian — at least here in the States as it is dominant in Europe — are also rans.

6 thoughts on “iPhone v. BlackBerry: Which to Choose?

  1. I couldn’t have said it better.

    RIM’s bread is enterprise and given Apple has never been strong there AND it is currently stretched in 10 different (consumer-oriened) directions I just don’t see any threat to RIM any day soon.

    Their biggest enemy is…RIM themselves. I wouldn’t try to outperform Apple’s design and wow factor if I was them, but instead focus on improving and/or revolutionalizing the etnerprise sector once again.

  2. I have used the iPhone and typing is easy after it learns your tendencies. Apple just created solutions for exchange and the third party apps. So, I hope that the power-one calculators will become available for iPhones.

  3. I would agree about RIM, Bobby. I think they need to accelerate the pace of change. They have not been great at speed. I think they also need to start thinking off-device (supporting software) for folks beyond Exchange and Enterprise.

    Cara, thanks for asking. We rolled out FastFigures just last week. FastFigures is a web-service for calculation and result reporting. It works wonderfully on the iPhone, as well as Mac, Windows, BlackBerry, Windows Mobile and Palm OS devices. Please check it out here:

  4. Pingback: Windows Mobile: Dead or Alive? « Mobile Success

  5. Pingback: Touchscreen Wars « Mobile Success

  6. Pingback: iPhone Software - PalmPilot Redux « Mobile Success

Comments are closed.